I like no.2 and I also really like one of the other ones you posted on the 2000ad forum... the first on I think, it really captured something about Dredd.
Really? Thank you kindly sir! Funnily enough I wasn't even going to bother inking or scanning that one. Yeah, no.2 has the old school feel I reckon - it's a toss up for me between 2 and 5.
Number 2 for me! It's got a bit of an old school look and the best helmet,if that's any help